How many jane eyre versions are there

Thursday must enter Jane Eyre herself to prevent Hades from committing literary homicide. She points out that Thursday Next is remarkably similar to Jane Eyre, being very independent and opinionated. Supernatural intervention has a similar effect on her as it does on Jane:.

Ultimately, Thursday is reunited with her crippled lover after years of separation, and they are married. Hateley As times change, so do the concerns of Jane Eyre readers. I often find, for example, that some people are concerned about the age difference between Jane and Rochester. How young can an actress playing Jane look without turning off some viewers? Attitudes toward such a relationship will always be shifting.

One thing that remains steady since is the enduring appeal of the novel itself. IMDb posters also weigh in on why they love the story. And the love between [Jane] and Rochester was as real as literature can make it be. As you can see from these boards, they are so finely drawn that people draw blood over who should play them, as they do Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet. Jane and Rochester knew the worst of one another, and persisted, because of the good in what each was, and in spite of what each was not.

And in the end, there is redemption. The story has scope, love, despair, mystery, drama, suffering and finally, redemption. That's been a successful formula many are drawn to for centuries. I have already described why I am drawn to the novel. Berardinelli, James. Bowman, James. Academic Search Complete. Sturgis Library, Kennesaw. Bronteana, ed. Campbell, Gardner. MLA International Bibliography. Ellis, Kate, and E. Ann Kaplan. Michael Klein and Gillian Parker.

New York: Ungar, Hateley, Erica. Internet Movie Database. Miller, Lucasta. I would be very happy to be known as an Eyreholic though I must admit, I saw many of the movies first before I actually started reading the book, and I have to say as well that I disagree with many points the critics made. First the simplest; though Ms. Bronte wrote Pilot to be a rather large dog; I prefer the different dogs chosen for the various movie versions I prefer. I don't associate with a large Pilot; rather a dog that could be used as a shepherd dog as much of the income for an estate came from sheep.

I do not like the George C. Scott movie version as I think there is no depth to his depiction of Mr. Rochester, he is milktoast. I very much prefer both the Toby Stephens version as well as the William Hurt versions as they best show the broodiness that Rochester was supposed to have. I do think I like the Toby Stephens version best because he does treat Jane as the human being she deserves to be, and I feel for Jane when she is insulted by Rochester's guests.

I do want to say also that I have absolutely no interest in Ms. Rhys' "prequel" Wide Sargasso Sea. I will admit, I've not read the story, but only plot overviews, but in my opinion there is too much that was done in this novel that makes mistakes about the why's and wherefores of Ms. Bronte's work.

For example; Bertha was actually a rather popular name in Ms. Bronte's England, so to me it makes no sense that the character of Antoinette would beg Rochester to stop calling her that. Second, I've read other blogs that complained about Rochester claiming that the comforts he tried to provide for Bertha made her better off than if she were sent to an asylum.

The problem is that this was true. In those days asylums were more often than not dirty, over-crowded, and abusive. Most people sentenced to an asylum died there, and were often chained to the walls of their cells. Finally, though the science of mental health was only just emerging, it was hard enough for Ms.

Bronte to find an actual possible diagnosis for Bertha, but she did try, and there is actually a possible real-life diagnosis for what Bertha could have suffered from. Today it is called Intermittent Explosive Disorder, and the majority, if not all the symptoms Bertha is shown to have in the way Ms.

Bronte wrote the book actually match up with this diagnosis. For these reasons I would not be interested in Ms. Rhys' novel as it is too different than the original story written by Ms. I've seen at least 7 versions of the novel. I like at least four of them and love three versions. The ones I love are the versions from , and I loved the BBC series with Michael Jayston - for me, he is the quintessential Rochester though it's a few years since I saw it so maybe it won't stand up against some of the more recent versions.

Nice Hub. Joan Fontaine was 26 years old when the movie was shot. She wasn't too old for the role. Please read the book. The book describes "a great dog, whose black and white colour made him a distinct object against the trees I have a lb black Newfoundland Service Dog named "Bubbles".

Read the book. Depict the accuracy of the book. I haven't seen the Charlton Heston version and I've seen only short clips of the one. In the novel, Mr. Though he appears brusque, Mr. Rochester shares a sensitivity with Jane that ultimately turns her heart towards him.

Fassbender, commits to Mr. Wasikowska is as restrained as her corset-clad waist. In the novel, there is a fire and intelligence in her that is evidenced by her ability to hold her own while jesting with Mr.

Unfortunately, the ease of verbal sparring does not translate as well on screen; the audience does not see two intellectual equals grow closer through a mutual sense of humor, but rather a cold man suddenly declare love for an inscrutable woman.

She is quietly defiant when told she is to be relocated to Lowood School. For such a small child, she possesses the courage of conviction that defines Jane Eyre as a character. This adaptation modifies the scene from the novel in which Jane inadvertently drops her slate.

Brocklehust, discovers her without her cap. In an act of solidarity, Jane comes forward and demands that her long locks be hacked too. Rochester are tender lovers that yearn for each other in wounded silence. In the novel, Jane is forced to sleep outdoors and beg for food while attempting to escape the temptation to live as Mr.

In the film, Jane only endures a long coach ride back to Gateshead where she becomes acquainted with St. John Rivers. The development of this relationship is brief and unremarkable. Without it, the film suffers a loss of key character exposition. While some literary elements are lost to Hollywood, Gainsbourg and Hurt make up for this shortcoming by imbuing a strong sense of intimacy between their characters.

Rochester to stand from his solitary chair — though precariously — with his cane. The pair bolster each other and share a long-awaited and passionate kiss. Their coming together again at the end of the film is a sweet reconciliation between the screen and the page. Much of the screenplay and character building is sourced directly from the novel.

With abundant time to develop the plot, the two lead actors are given form to fleshed-out versions of their characters. Didn't Like: Brevity of story, background, relationship devolpment. A young governess falls in love with her mysterious employer, but a terrible secret puts their happiness at risk. Votes: 3, You truly feel his desperate need for Jane. Didn't like: Zelah's performance as Jane Poor Production.

Jane Eyre is an orphan cast out as a young girl by her aunt, Mrs. Reed, and sent to be raised in a harsh charity school for girls.

There she learns to become a teacher and eventually seeks See full summary ». Jane was a ghost of what she should be. Approved 97 min Drama, Romance. After a harsh childhood, orphan Jane Eyre is hired by Edward Rochester, the brooding lord of a mysterious manor house, to care for his young daughter. People who know me would assume I'd like this version best since I've always been into classic movies.

They did an excellent job. Peggy Ann Garner as little Jane is perfection. Little Taylor did well also. With long shadows and stark black-white contrast, the locations feel the way they are described in the book.

Lowood feels lonely and oppressive, while Thornfield feels truly haunted by secrets bordering on the supernatural. Orson Welles gives a fantastic performance as Rochester, commanding every scene he is in. The actor's larger-than-life screen presence is perfect for the character and the story. Here is another version that aired as a television series on BBC. These four episodes cover everything in the novel, from Gateshead to Moor House.

Scenes with Jane and Rochester pulse with romance and mystery, and the chemistry between Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens is undeniable. Certain changes are made to the dialogue in an attempt to modernize the story for newer audiences, and these changes may not work for everyone.

Each version has its strengths, but no other has captured the essence of the novel the way that the version has.

Director Cary Fukunaga and screenwriter Moira Buffini make the brilliant decision to begin the movie with Jane fleeing Thornfield. The rest of the story—Jane's childhood, her romance with Rochester, her attempted marriage—is told through flashbacks. This improves the pacing of the film and keeps the audience engaged. Though many actors have put their own spin on these characters, this cast cannot be matched.

Michael Fassbender is a nearly perfect Rochester. Meanwhile, Judi Dench and Jamie Bell , as well as the rest of the supporting cast, give great performances, as well.